The officials emphasized that vaccine hesitancy among Republicans could threaten herd immunity and Trump’s followers will listen to him — and pretty much only him.
“Vaccines are widely regarded as one of Trump’s greatest accomplishments, and Trump understands that this legacy is at risk because half of his supporters are not taking the vaccine,” one of the officials said. “It’s just not clear yet if he understands that he’s the only one who can fix this.”
The other official agreed.
“In Trump country, if you want to call it that, there are still significant numbers of people who aren’t sure [Covid-19] is a real thing, despite folks getting sick, and there are lots of suspicions about the vaccine,” the source said. “They have literally said to me, ‘I want to hear from the president about this.’ I don’t think they’re going to listen to anyone else.”
Trump told Fox News last week that he would make a “commercial” about the vaccine, but did not make a firm commitment.
“They want me to make a video,” Trump said in his April 19 interview with host Sean Hannity. “They want me to do a commercial saying take the vaccine, and they think that’s very important and I’d certainly do it.”
However, a person close to Trump disagreed he should take this approach. “He shouldn’t be pushing these vaccines. His posse isn’t exactly vaccine-approving and it could backfire,” the person said.
A Trump spokesperson declined to comment for this story.
Trump didn’t participate in ad campaign with other former presidents
It’s a basic public health principle: Get respected voices — such as politicians, celebrities or athletes — to advocate for a particular public health measure, and others will likely follow.
Trump’s team says he was not asked to participate in the PSA featuring the former presidents, according to a senior Trump adviser.
In the Fox interview, Trump said, “I encourage them to take it. I do,” referring to his supporters.
However, Trump has actually spoken up only a few times to encourage vaccination.
In a February 28 speech to the Conservative Political Action Conference in Orlando, Florida, Trump told the audience “how unpainful that vaccine shot is, so everybody go get your shot.”
“The vaccine is a great thing and people should take advantage of it,” Trump told columnist Michael Goodwin. “Nobody should be forced, we have our freedoms. But I strongly recommend it because it’s a real lifesaver.”
Most Republicans hesitant to get the vaccine
In that survey of 1,862 adults, 29% of Republicans said they would definitely not get a vaccine; 6% said they would only get it if required, 19% said they would wait and see and 46% said they had already gotten it or would get it soon as possible.
Those attitudes have translated to relatively low uptake of the vaccine in many states that voted for Trump in the 2020 election.
According to a CNN analysis looking at the percentage of those 18 and older with at least one dose of the Covid-19 vaccine, the top 10 states are: New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Vermont, New Mexico, Maine, New Jersey, Hawaii, Rhode Island and California. All are states President Joe Biden won last November.
The bottom 10 states in this metric Mississippi, Alabama, Louisiana, Tennessee, Wyoming, West Virginia, Georgia, Idaho, Arkansas and South Carolina. Trump won all of those states last year, except for Georgia.
A third former Trump official said there were concerns as early as last summer that too many Republicans would say no to the vaccine.
“On Facebook I saw a ton of hesitancy for that group — just insane amounts of hesitancy already and we knew it was just going to get worse,” the official said.
That official said Trump ally Michael Caputo briefly mentioned to Trump last fall that it would be good for the president to do a vaccine PSA after the election.
One of the other former officials noted that recently, Caputo “in particular has been active in discussing” the possibility of doing a PSA with the Trump team.
“Michael takes this very seriously and sees this as a big public health problem,” the source said. “His stepping out, because he’s so connected to the president, is really going to be forceful and incredibly helpful.”
Former aide met with Trump in April
Caputo confirmed to CNN that he met with Trump at Mar-a-Lago on April 7 and the two men “spoke about vaccine hesitancy and what can be done about it.”
The former Trump administration officials said they don’t want to see Trump’s efforts to develop a Covid-19 vaccine — dubbed Operation Warp Speed — undone by vaccine hesitancy, including hesitancy among his own supporters.
“I see Operation Warp Speed tipping towards failure, and it really concerns me,” one of the senior officials said. “If we don’t move half those people into the vaccinated column, we’re most likely not going to reach community immunity, and if we don’t reach it, then the president’s vaccine legacy is dead.”
The other senior official said Trump supporters would respond well to the former president “taking ownership of Operation Warp Speed” and discussing how he and the former first lady were both vaccinated.
“He could talk about how [vaccine uptake] is the way to get the country back to where it needs to be economically and socially, using his language that he uses with his supporters. I think that would be really powerful,” the source said.
CNN’s Deidre McPhillips, Gabby Orr and Naomi Thomas contributed to this story.